Walk-In Tubs vs. Traditional – Which Bathtub Fits You Best?

May 28, 202413 min read

Ever find yourself in a bubble bath debate, torn between the classic comfort of a traditional bathtub and the modern perks of a walk-in tub? You're not alone! Whether you're upgrading your bathroom or planning a new one, choosing the right bathtub can be a real head-scratcher.

But fear not, dear reader! We're here to help you navigate the bubbly waters of decision-making. In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between walk-in tubs and traditional bathtubs, so you can choose the one that’s perfect for your lifestyle.

Why does this matter? Because your bathtub transcends mere cleanliness. It's your haven, a retreat to unwind, destress, and perhaps even hum a tune or two (no judgment here!). And if you find yourself in Sacramento, consider yourself fortunate—excellent choices like Walk-In Tubs in Sacramento are available, tailored to your preferences. What's more, companies such as American Therapy Tubs present an array of top-quality options.

So, grab your rubber ducky, and let’s dive into the bubbly debate of walk-in tubs vs. traditional bathtubs! Which one will fit you best? Read on to find out!

Understanding Walk-In Tubs

a senior enjoying the walk-in tub

Alright, bubble enthusiasts, let's start with the star of the show: walk-in tubs! These beauties are the ultimate game-changer, especially if you’re all about safety, comfort, and a dash of luxury.

So, what exactly is a walk-in tub? Picture this: a bathtub with a door! Yep, you read that right. Walk-in tubs are designed with a door on the side that opens and closes securely, allowing you to step in and out without having to perform any gymnastics. No more high hurdles or risky balancing acts!

But wait, there’s more! These tubs come packed with features that make them a serious contender for your bathroom upgrade. Let’s break down the cool stuff:

Door Entry: The door is the star feature, eliminating the need to climb over the tub’s edge. Just open the door, walk in, and you’re ready to soak.

Built-in Seat: These tubs typically have a comfy built-in seat, so you can sit back and relax without fully immersing yourself if you prefer.

Handrails: Safety first! Handrails provide extra support, making it easier to maneuver inside the tub.

Hydrotherapy Jets: Feeling fancy? Many walk-in tubs come with hydrotherapy jets that can turn your bath into a spa-like experience, helping to soothe sore muscles and joints.

Who can benefit from these features? Walk-in tubs are especially great for:

Seniors: As we age, mobility can become an issue. Walk-in tubs offer a safer way to enjoy a bath without the risk of slips and falls.

People with Mobility Issues: If you have mobility challenges due to injury, disability, or chronic conditions, these tubs make bathing more accessible and less stressful.

Anyone Seeking Comfort and Safety: Honestly, anyone who values comfort and safety in their bathing routine will appreciate a walk-in tub.

In a nutshell, walk-in tubs are all about making your bathing experience safer, more comfortable, and yes, a bit more luxurious. And if you’re looking for options in Sacramento, you’ve got some fantastic choices with Walk-In Tubs in Sacramento and Walk-In Therapy Tubs in Sacramento, including top picks from American Therapy Tubs.

Traditional Bathtubs Explained

Next up in our bubble bath showdown: the classic, the timeless, the ever-reliable traditional bathtub. These beauties have been around forever and for good reason. Let's dive into what makes them so beloved and whether they might be the perfect fit for your home.

What exactly is a traditional bathtub? Think of it as the classic tub we all know and love. It’s that rectangular fixture sitting in your bathroom, ready to offer you a relaxing soak at the end of a long day. No frills, no fuss—just pure, unadulterated bathing bliss.

Traditional bathtubs come in a variety of styles and materials, each bringing its own charm and functionality to your bathroom. Let’s break it down:

Standard Size and Shape: Most traditional tubs are rectangular and come in standard sizes, making them a versatile fit for many bathrooms.

Material Variations: These tubs can be made from different materials like acrylic, porcelain, and cast iron, each offering different benefits. Acrylic is lightweight and easy to install, porcelain has a classic look, and cast iron is durable and retains heat well.


  • Freestanding: These tubs stand alone and can be placed anywhere in your bathroom. They often come in beautiful, eye-catching designs.

  • Alcove: The most common type, nestled between three walls, saving space and making for easy shower conversions.

  • Corner: Perfect for making use of corner spaces, adding a unique touch to your bathroom layout.

So, who are traditional bathtubs best suited for? Let’s see:

Families: These tubs are perfect for families, providing ample space for kids to splash around and have fun.

Luxury Bath Lovers: If you love a long, relaxing soak, traditional tubs, especially the freestanding varieties, offer a deep and luxurious bathing experience.

Homeowners with Space: Traditional tubs, especially the larger or freestanding types, require a bit more bathroom space, making them ideal for bigger bathrooms.

Traditional bathtubs are all about that classic bathing experience, blending simplicity with style. They might not have all the bells and whistles of walk-in tubs, but they more than make up for it with their timeless appeal and variety.

Whether you’re a family looking for a practical bathing solution, or someone who loves to indulge in a long, hot soak, traditional bathtubs have got you covered. 

Pros and Cons: Walk-In Tubs

Alright, let’s take a closer look at walk-in tubs. They might sound like a dream come true, but like any home improvement choice, they come with their own set of pros and cons. Let’s dive in and see what makes walk-in tubs fantastic and what might give you pause.


  • Enhanced Safety

    Safety is the name of the game here. Walk-in tubs are designed to minimize the risk of slips and falls, making them a top pick for seniors and anyone with mobility issues. With features like low entry thresholds, built-in handrails, and non-slip floors, these tubs are all about giving you peace of mind.

  • Easier Access

    No more awkward climbing or balancing acts! The door feature in walk-in tubs means you can simply open the door, step in, and sit down. It’s as easy as walking into your living room—just with more bubbles.

  • Therapeutic Benefits

    Many walk-in tubs come equipped with hydrotherapy jets that can help soothe sore muscles, reduce stress, and even improve circulation. Imagine having a mini-spa right in your bathroom. Whether you’re dealing with arthritis or just need a relaxing soak, these jets can make a world of difference.


  • Higher Cost

    Here’s the kicker: walk-in tubs can be pretty pricey. They typically cost more than traditional bathtubs, both in terms of the tub itself and the installation. You’re looking at a higher upfront investment, which might be a deal-breaker if you’re on a tight budget.

  • Installation Complexity

    Speaking of installation, it’s not always a straightforward process. Depending on your bathroom’s current setup, installing a walk-in tub can require significant modifications. You might need a professional to handle the plumbing and installation, adding to the overall cost and time involved.

  • Longer Filling and Draining Time

    Patience is a virtue, especially with walk-in tubs. Since you have to be inside the tub before filling it up (and stay inside until it drains), the process can take a bit longer than with a traditional bathtub. This means waiting a while before you can start your soak and after you finish.

Walk-in tubs offer unmatched safety, easy access, and therapeutic benefits, making them a fantastic choice for those who prioritize these features. However, the higher cost, complex installation, and longer filling and draining times are important factors to consider. If you’re in the Sacramento area, options like Walk-In Tubs in Sacramento and Walk-In Therapy Tubs in Sacramento from companies like American Therapy Tubs can provide great choices that cater to your specific needs.

Pros and Cons: Traditional Bathtubs

a classic, elegant bathtub filled with bubbles

Now that we've soaked up the details on walk-in tubs, let's turn our attention to the ever-classic traditional bathtubs. These timeless fixtures have graced bathrooms for generations, and they come with their own set of advantages and drawbacks. Let's dive in!


  • Variety of Styles and Sizes

    Traditional bathtubs are the chameleons of the bathroom world. Whether you want a sleek, modern look or something more vintage, there’s a traditional tub to match. Freestanding, alcove, or corner—there's a style and size for every bathroom setup and personal taste.

  • Lower Cost

    Budget-conscious bathers, rejoice! Traditional bathtubs are generally more affordable than walk-in tubs. From the cost of the tub itself to the installation, these tubs offer great value, making them an attractive option if you’re looking to upgrade without breaking the bank.

  • Easier Installation

    In most cases, installing a traditional bathtub is straightforward, especially if you’re replacing an existing tub. This can save you time, money, and a few headaches compared to the more complex installation required for walk-in tubs.


  • Accessibility Issues

    Here’s where traditional tubs can fall short: accessibility. Climbing over the side of the tub can be a challenge, particularly for seniors, kids, or anyone with mobility issues. Safety can be a concern, especially without additional safety features like grab bars or non-slip surfaces.

  • Fewer Therapeutic Features

    While a long soak in a traditional tub can be incredibly relaxing, these tubs typically lack the therapeutic features found in many walk-in models. No hydrotherapy jets here—just good old-fashioned water and bubbles.

  • Standard Safety Measures

    Traditional bathtubs often come with standard safety features, which might not be enough for everyone. If safety is a top priority, you might need to invest in additional accessories, such as non-slip mats or grab bars, to make your traditional tub safer.

Traditional bathtubs shine with their variety of styles, affordability, and easy installation, making them a popular choice for many households. However, they can pose accessibility challenges and usually lack the therapeutic bells and whistles of walk-in tubs. If you love a classic soak and have the space, a traditional bathtub might be just what you need.

As you weigh your options, remember that both types of tubs have their unique perks and drawbacks. Consider your personal needs, budget, and bathroom space before making a decision. 

Key Factors to Consider

Alright, bath enthusiasts, it's decision time! Choosing between a walk-in tub and a traditional bathtub is no small feat. To help you make the right choice, let’s dive into some key factors you should consider before taking the plunge.

Safety Needs

First and foremost, let’s talk safety. Assess your or your family members' mobility and safety requirements. If you or a loved one struggles with balance or mobility, a walk-in tub with features like low entry thresholds and handrails might be the safer choice. On the other hand, if everyone in your household is agile and sure-footed, a traditional bathtub might suffice.


Ah, the big B-word: budget. Consider the cost of both the tub itself and the installation. Walk-in tubs generally come with a higher price tag, so if you’re on a tight budget, a traditional bathtub might be the more wallet-friendly option. Remember to factor in any additional costs, like plumbing modifications or accessories, when crunching the numbers.

Bathroom Space

Size matters, especially when it comes to your bathtub! Evaluate the available space in your bathroom to determine which type of tub will fit best. Walk-in tubs typically require more space due to their door entry design, so if you have a cozy bathroom, make sure you have enough room to accommodate one comfortably. Traditional bathtubs come in various sizes, making them a more flexible option for smaller spaces.

Lifestyle Preferences

Last but certainly not least, consider your lifestyle preferences. How often do you bathe? Do you prefer a quick shower or a long, luxurious soak? Are therapeutic features like hydrotherapy jets a must-have, or are you content with a simple soak? Your bathing habits and relaxation needs should play a significant role in your decision-making process.

Choosing between a walk-in tub and a traditional bathtub boils down to your personal needs, budget, and lifestyle. If safety and accessibility are top priorities, a walk-in tub might be the way to go. If you’re looking for affordability and versatility, a traditional bathtub could be your best bet. Take the time to weigh the pros and cons, consider these key factors, and ultimately choose the tub that fits you and your home like a glove.

Making the Decision

a homeowner consulting with a bathroom contractor

Congratulations, bath aficionados! You’ve made it to the final stretch of our bubbly journey: decision time. Choosing the perfect bathtub for your home is no small feat, but fear not! We’re here to help you weigh the pros and cons, consider your needs, and ultimately make the decision that’s right for you.

Let’s start by breaking out the big guns: the decision matrix. Grab a pen and paper (or your favorite note-taking app) and create a simple table. On one side, list the key factors that are most important to you—safety, budget, bathroom space, and lifestyle preferences. On the other side, jot down how each type of tub (walk-in or traditional) stacks up against those factors. This visual aid can help you see the pros and cons at a glance and make a more informed decision.

Now, let’s tap into the wisdom of the pros. Reach out to home improvement experts, bathroom designers, and even occupational therapists for their insights. They can offer valuable advice tailored to your specific needs and preferences. Don’t be afraid to ask questions and gather as much information as possible before making your decision.

As you mull over your options, here’s a friendly piece of advice: trust your gut. You know yourself and your household better than anyone else. Consider your daily routines, bathing habits, and long-term needs. Which type of tub feels like the best fit for your lifestyle? Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer—choose the tub that speaks to you and meets your unique requirements.

And there you have it, bath buddies! We've journeyed through the bubbly world of walk-in tubs and traditional bathtubs, exploring their features, pros, and cons to help you make the best decision for your home. Whether you're craving the safety and convenience of a walk-in tub or the timeless charm of a traditional bathtub, the choice is yours!

As you embark on your bathtub adventure, remember to consider your safety needs, budget, bathroom space, and lifestyle preferences. Use our handy decision matrix to weigh the pros and cons, seek advice from experts, and trust your instincts. After all, your bathtub should be a sanctuary—a place where you can relax, unwind, and wash away the stresses of the day.

If you're in the Sacramento area and ready to turn your bathroom dreams into reality, look no further than Adaptive Living Renovations and American Therapy Tubs. These trusted Sacramento bathroom contractors specialize in creating beautiful, functional spaces tailored to your needs. Whether you're planning a full-scale bathroom renovation or simply upgrading your bathtub, they've got you covered.

So go ahead, take the plunge! Your perfect bathtub awaits. And if you ever need a helping hand along the way, don't hesitate to reach out to the experts. Happy bathing, everyone!

Back to Blog